An Enlightened Layperson's Analysis of the New FISA Bill
Sigh!! So the Democrats have caved and given George Bush just what he wanted in terms of FISA modifications. Before giving way to general outrage, the first order of business should be to understand just what Congress has enacted and why.
For reasons that have not been made public, one of the FISA judges recently ruled that the Administration was in violation of FISA. Although the what the judge ruled is unknown, there is a general consensus on what happened. FISA, in its original form, did not require a warrant to listen in to calls taking place entirely outside the United States. Since FISA was enacted, however, calls are increasingly sent over fiber optic cables that may be far from the actual people talking. A call between two people outside the United States may pass through a cable in the US. It is believed the court ruled that a warrant would be required to listen in to such a cable. This was generally agreed to be a flaw in need of correction. The difference between Congressional Democrats and the Administration was how much leeway to allow listening into such a cable.
A comparison between the old law, the proposed Democratic bill, and the Administration's bill that passed is as follows:
The old FISA law:
So, what are the important differences?
With regard to when a warrant is required, the old FISA did not specify any particular calls not requiring a warrant. However, reading the definitions closely, one can see that it did not require a warrant for any communications taking place entirely outside the United States or international radio communications. More controversially, FISA required a warrant for "any wire communication to or from a person in the United States, without the consent of any party thereto, if such acquisition occurs in the United States." This would seem indicate that if the NSA wiretapped a person outside the US, and if the wiretap itself took place outside the US, they could listen in on that person's calls with someone inside the US. However, the NSA could not monitor such a call from a switch inside the US. (This was the crux of the debate over warrantless surveillance; was a warrant required to listen to calls in and out of the US).
The Democratic version excludes from warrant only "communications between persons that are not located within the United States . . . without respect to whether the communication passes through the United States or the surveillance device is located within the United States." This would still require a warrant to wiretap calls between the US and other countries, if the wiretap occurred within the US. The Administration version exempts surveillance "directed at a person reasonably believed to be located outside of the United States." Wiretapping of international calls in and out of the United States would not require a warrant so long as the target was "reasonably believed" not to be in the country. The huge question here is whether "directed at a person reasonably believed to be located outside of the United States" means that our international call can be wiretapped without a warrant only if the person on the other end is a specific target, or if any international call is fair game.
Obviously, there are major enforcement differences between the bills. In the Democratic version, the Attorney General would have to show the court that he was using procedures to protect American calls from surveillance before beginning. In the Administration bill, the AG and DNI have four to six months of unsupervised surveillance, and the FISA court can reign them in only if their procedures are "clearly erroneous." How alarming this is all depends on how far you trust Alberto Gonzales, I guess.
Finally, all versions are superficially similar in requiring telecommunications companies to participate in wiretapping and immunizing them from liability for complying. However, Professor Orin Kerr points out that there is a difference between the Administration version and either the Democratic version or the old FISA. The Administration version compels compliance with an executive order (with the opportunity to appeal it to court). The other versions require compliance with a court order.
Next: Does it matter that the Democrats won last November?
Update: JAO, at Balkinization, adds a new wrinkle. The Attorney General is not required to make the certifications provided in the new law. JAO believes that the new statute permits the NSA to listen in to any calls between the US and other countries, even without the AG certifying that "reasonable procedures" were used to ensure the surveillance was "directed at" people outside the US, the surveillance was for foreign intelligence, or that minimization procedures were used. However, without such certification, the government cannot compel telecommunications companies to cooperate. (Nor, presumably, would they be immune from liability).
Second update:
Occasional Observer on why JAO's interpretation is probably wrong. Speaking solely as an Enlightened Layperson, I am inclined to agree with Occasional Observer.
For reasons that have not been made public, one of the FISA judges recently ruled that the Administration was in violation of FISA. Although the what the judge ruled is unknown, there is a general consensus on what happened. FISA, in its original form, did not require a warrant to listen in to calls taking place entirely outside the United States. Since FISA was enacted, however, calls are increasingly sent over fiber optic cables that may be far from the actual people talking. A call between two people outside the United States may pass through a cable in the US. It is believed the court ruled that a warrant would be required to listen in to such a cable. This was generally agreed to be a flaw in need of correction. The difference between Congressional Democrats and the Administration was how much leeway to allow listening into such a cable.
A comparison between the old law, the proposed Democratic bill, and the Administration's bill that passed is as follows:
The old FISA law:
- Defined "electronic surveillance" requiring a warrant as (1) surveillance intentionally targeting of a "United States person" (citizen or permanent legal resident) within the US, or (2) surveillance of the wire communications of a person in the United States, if the acquisition takes place within the US, or (3) surveillance of radio communications between people within the US, or (4) any other surveillance within the US that might come up.
- Permitted surveillance without a warrant inside the US for periods of up to one year if the Attorney General certified in writing that that it applied only to foreign governments or embassies and that appropriate "minimization procedures" were applied. (Minimization procedures are rules for limitnig innnocent information that may be accidentally obtained).
- Established procedures for applying for FISA warrants.
- Commanded the judge to issue a warrant if (1) there is probable cause to believe the target is an "agent of a foreign power" (including terrorist organizations), (2) minimization procedures are adequate, and (3) the application has been properly prepared and, if the target is a US person, is not "clearly erroneous."
- Required telecommunications companies to comply with FISA warrants and immunized them from liability for complying with FISA.
The Democratic bill would have:
- Made clear that foreign-to-foreign communications routed through the United States do not require a FISA warrant, even if the surveillance takes place within the US.
- Required the Attorney General to submit an application to the FISA court for a one-year order explaining (1) how it is determined that targets of the surveillance are outside the US, (2) the general information being sought and "foreign power" (incuding terrorist organization) that is the target (although individual persons and places need not be named), and (3) minimization procedures being used.
- Commanded the judge to grant the order if (1) the surveillance is not a kind requiring personal FISA warrants, (2) the methods described are reasonably designed to determine whether the persons are outside the US, (3) foreign intelligence is a "significant purpose" of the surveillance, and (4) minimization procedures are adequate.
- Required telecommunications companies to comply with the court order and immunized them from liability for complying.
- Makes clear that FISA warrants are not required for surveillance "directed at a person reasonably believed to be located outside the United States."
- Gives the Attorney General and Director of National Intelligence authority to authorize such surveillance for one year without a court order, provided they certify (1) there are reasonable procedures in place for determining the people surveilled are outside the US, (2) no individual FISA warrant is required, (3) foreign intelligence is a "significant purpose" of the surveillance, and (4) minimization procedures are adequate.
- Provides for court review of the Attorney General's guidelines 4 to 6 months after the law is enacted. The court may rule against the government only if it finds the determination is "clearly erroneous."
- Requires telecommunications companies to comply with the AG and DNI directives and immunize them from liability for complying. Companies could challenge the legality of such a directive in the FISA court.
So, what are the important differences?
With regard to when a warrant is required, the old FISA did not specify any particular calls not requiring a warrant. However, reading the definitions closely, one can see that it did not require a warrant for any communications taking place entirely outside the United States or international radio communications. More controversially, FISA required a warrant for "any wire communication to or from a person in the United States, without the consent of any party thereto, if such acquisition occurs in the United States." This would seem indicate that if the NSA wiretapped a person outside the US, and if the wiretap itself took place outside the US, they could listen in on that person's calls with someone inside the US. However, the NSA could not monitor such a call from a switch inside the US. (This was the crux of the debate over warrantless surveillance; was a warrant required to listen to calls in and out of the US).
The Democratic version excludes from warrant only "communications between persons that are not located within the United States . . . without respect to whether the communication passes through the United States or the surveillance device is located within the United States." This would still require a warrant to wiretap calls between the US and other countries, if the wiretap occurred within the US. The Administration version exempts surveillance "directed at a person reasonably believed to be located outside of the United States." Wiretapping of international calls in and out of the United States would not require a warrant so long as the target was "reasonably believed" not to be in the country. The huge question here is whether "directed at a person reasonably believed to be located outside of the United States" means that our international call can be wiretapped without a warrant only if the person on the other end is a specific target, or if any international call is fair game.
Obviously, there are major enforcement differences between the bills. In the Democratic version, the Attorney General would have to show the court that he was using procedures to protect American calls from surveillance before beginning. In the Administration bill, the AG and DNI have four to six months of unsupervised surveillance, and the FISA court can reign them in only if their procedures are "clearly erroneous." How alarming this is all depends on how far you trust Alberto Gonzales, I guess.
Finally, all versions are superficially similar in requiring telecommunications companies to participate in wiretapping and immunizing them from liability for complying. However, Professor Orin Kerr points out that there is a difference between the Administration version and either the Democratic version or the old FISA. The Administration version compels compliance with an executive order (with the opportunity to appeal it to court). The other versions require compliance with a court order.
Next: Does it matter that the Democrats won last November?
Update: JAO, at Balkinization, adds a new wrinkle. The Attorney General is not required to make the certifications provided in the new law. JAO believes that the new statute permits the NSA to listen in to any calls between the US and other countries, even without the AG certifying that "reasonable procedures" were used to ensure the surveillance was "directed at" people outside the US, the surveillance was for foreign intelligence, or that minimization procedures were used. However, without such certification, the government cannot compel telecommunications companies to cooperate. (Nor, presumably, would they be immune from liability).
Second update:
Occasional Observer on why JAO's interpretation is probably wrong. Speaking solely as an Enlightened Layperson, I am inclined to agree with Occasional Observer.
Labels: Wiretapping
171 Comments:
[b][url=http://www.uggsunitedkingdom.co.uk/]ugg boots uk[/url][/b] The South Korean federal government is probably going to permit credit score card firms to provide inventory trading services to deregulate the fiscal companies subject. Our report has examined the rising market tendencies like, investing products and services, the latest developments, as well as their influence on the marketplace. The report should help clients evaluate the leading-edge possibilities, possible client foundation, critical people, future outlook, and all other factors, which are crucial on the achievement of the new entrant inside the South Korean Cost Card Market..
[b][url=http://www.uggsoutletsite.co.uk/]ugg boots outlet[/url][/b] one. State Your Intent. Extra conveniently said- what would you price? Discover out what on earth is truly vital for you. A dimensions six just isn't all of that terribly tiny. I can think she matches it - especially if she's not tall. You are able to be Not Tall and possess curves along with a 6 will would you high-quality.
[b][url=http://www.lovelouisvuittonbags.co.uk/]louis vuitton purses[/url][/b] Start out contributing as soon and just as much as feasible. Beginning in a young age will increase your possibilities of having a nice nest egg at retirement. Time and compounding can perform to suit your needs.. Right after you've got seriously requested and answered each individual of those queries, you may have designed a much greater focus on your locker organizer ambitions. Keep in mind not to purchase an organizer since it in some way looks neat in its individual ideal. Only integrate products that assist you transfer in and out of your locker with the biggest of simplicity..
[b][url=http://www.uggsoutletsite.co.uk/]www.uggsoutletsite.co.uk[/url][/b] From handbags so as to housewares, everything now there in completely appointed circumstances and hanging from thoroughly clean, hideously expensive vintage hermes scarves racks. That is certainly why a Birkin will expense reproduction Louis Vuitton wallet you 10 grand another person will need to pay the interior layout and model invoice. The good news is, viewing that online video is absolutely free.
[b][url=http://www.seekingbestbags.co.uk/]louis vuitton purses[/url][/b] Particular home like automobiles, plane, and homes are susceptible to wreck, furthermore to livestock and plants. If hail damages your roof or siding, it could not merely look undesirable, it may well induce leaking. Otherwise preset shortly immediately after the hurt is performed, it may bring about costly problems and in depth repairs.
tramadol tramadol withdrawal length - buy tramadol online no prescription next day delivery
ativan no prescription ativan dosage intravenous - lorazepam ratio 1mg
buy tramadol online no prescription cheap buy tramadol online worldwide - buy tramadol online with american express
buy tramadol online cheap tramadol withdrawal effects - tramadol hcl uses
buy generic tramadol tramadol hcl gout - tramadol no prescription overnight
klonopin 2mg klonopin effects - klonopin ld50
buy tramadol cheap online buy tramadol buy cod - tramadol online to florida
2mg klonopin klonopin withdrawal jaw - buy klonopin online cheap
order tramadol no prescription tramadol 50 mg tablets - best place order tramadol
order tramadol no prescription tramadol dosage side effects - tramadol 50 mg vs tylenol #3
purchase klonopin klonopin side effects of - klonopin sublingual wafers
lorazepam online buy ativan online cheap - lorazepam 1 mg to buy
buy klonopin online does 2mg klonopin do - klonopin side effects and breastfeeding
tramadol online tramadol dosage 15 lb dog - buy tramadol with american express
buy ativan online apo-lorazepam 1 mg side effects - ativan yawning
tramadol online tramadol ultram ingredients - can you overdose tramadol 50mg
buy tramadol without rx tramadol online from usa - tramadol no prescription cheap
soma online aura soma buy - soma concert venue san diego
tramadol 100 mg order tramadol paypal - tramadol 50 mg good
ambien online ambien side effects addiction - ambien overdose many milligrams
order tramadol online without prescription tramadol 50mg my dog - tramadol high length
buy ambien online ambien side effects percentage - ambien cr recreational
generic ambien ambien cr urinary problems - ambien side effects bloating
somas online generic soma capsules - buy somatropin online usa
buy generic tramadol online what are the best sites to buy tramadol online - cheapest tramadol online no prescription needed
buy tramadol online cod tramadol 50 mg while breastfeeding - safe place buy tramadol online
cheap ativan lorazepam 1mg vs clonazepam - ativan withdrawal after 2 weeks
buy tramadol online buy ultram online no prescription - tramadol hcl 50 high
buy ambien ambien side effects erectile dysfunction - ambien side effects shaking
discount ativan ativan withdrawal heart palpitations - ativan generic watson
online soma buy soma online with cod - soma gym membership cost
tramadol cheap order tramadol online sweden - order tramadol online no rx
buy klonopin online generic klonopin accord - what does 2mg klonopin look like
buy tramadol overnight shipping what does tramadol high feel like - best buy tramadol
cheapest ambien cheapest ambien no prescription - generic medication ambien cr
order carisoprodol online soma order book - soma muscle relaxer drug test
ativan online ativan overdose amount - generic brand of ativan
cheap ambien no prescription ambien cr or ambien - ambien used alcohol withdrawal
buy tramadol mastercard can you buy tramadol mexico - tramadol high how much
klonopin medication klonopin blue pill - klonopin dosage recreational use
ambien pill ambien sleep length - buy ambien cr 12.5/ no prescription
soma online generic soma imprints - soma lingerie
viagra online purchase buy pink viagra women - online prescription viagra buy online
ambien pills ambien iv - ambien side effects on liver
buy viagra online buy viagra online thailand - buy viagra uk next day delivery
best buy tramadol tramadol street value - tramadol hcl max dosage
buy discount tramadol buy tramadol online overnight uk - can you buy tramadol legally online
buy tramadol online buy tramadol online in florida - tramadol buy online
discount ambien ambien cost walmart - generic ambien online + no prescription
viagra drug buy viagra online legally - viagra for women alternatives
order ambien online generic ambien doses - ambien overdose how much is too much
how to buy viagra online without buy viagra in uk over the counter - where to buy viagra online cheap
klonopin anxiety klonopin alcohol and weed - generic form klonopin
tramadol online order tramadol uk - tramadol 50 mg tab
buy viagra buy viagra online from canada - where to buy cheap viagra online
order viagra for women buy viagra online from canadian pharmacy - cheap viagra eu
buy soma soma online legal - drug test soma carisoprodol
buy viagra cheap online buy viagra online australia fast delivery - can you buy viagra vietnam
buy cialis online no prescription cialis 75 oral liquid - cialis online legale
buy viagra professional viagra online wiki - order viagra australia
buy tramadol online tramadol no prescription overnight shipping - tramadol 50 mg medicine
buy soma somo 650dx - soma drug abuse
viagra online viagra dosage nhs - viagra buy in australia
buy tramadol medication buy tramadol with cod - tramadol 50mg and ibuprofen
discount viagra buy viagra cialis online canada - viagra gel for women uk
buy viagra cheap cheap viagra pills sale - viagra for women commercial
order viagra from canada cheap viagra online fast shipping - generic viagra online canadian pharmacy
order cialis online no prescription cialis daily use dosage - cialis no prescription overnight
buy tramadol online mastercard overnight buy tramadol online australia - tramadol vs vicodin high
how to order viagra buy viagra hujagra 2011 - viagra for women online
where can i buy viagra online safely buy viagra online lloyds pharmacy - buy viagra paypal accepted
order viagra generic buy viagra online forum - buy viagra line uk
order viagra pills buy viagra online now - viagra dosage and usage
cialis online cialis online pharmacy australia - online rx for cialis
tramadol 100mg tramadol ultram addiction - tramadol hcl 200
purchase viagra no prescription cheap viagra super - purchase viagra germany
how to buy viagra online natural viagra for women uk - buy now viagra cialis
retin-a no prescription retin a acne dosage - retin a cream hair loss
tramadol without prescription buy tramadol 6914 - tramadol jaw pain
buy viagra next day delivery buy viagra online overnight - order viagra online canada
buy tramadol cod next day delivery tramadol apap - buy tramadol online cod no prescription
cheap viagra pills online purchase of viagra in india - viagra online scams
tramadol online pharmacy tramadol 0 1g - tramadol 50mg tablets narcotic
buy tramadol 100mg where to buy tramadol online - how to order tramadol
buy tramadol buy tramadol online mastercard overnight - buy tramadol an 627
buy propecia online propecia results crown - propecia after 40
tramadol online where can i purchase tramadol with a mastercard - tramadol high similar
propecia pharmacy propecia cost at costco - propecia 84
buy retin-a retin-a gel yahoo - retin a cream directions for use
buy strattera therapeutic dosage strattera - strattera dosage side effects
order tramadol tramadol yahoo answers - tramadol hcl and vicodin
tramadol 50 buy tramadol no prescription mastercard - tramadol cause addiction
buy retin-a online retin a micro initial breakout - discount retin a online
buy tramadol overnight cod buy cheapest tramadol online - tramadol to buy online in usa
tramadol online tramadol 50mg dosage for humans - buy tramadol no prescription needed
buy tramadol tramadol online in europe - tramadol hcl dosage adults
buy tramadol online no prescription cheap cheap tramadol sale - can you buy tramadol usa
tramadol online tramadol 717 - tramadol 50mg capsules dosage
buy tramadol free shipping buy tramadol online without rx - tramadol for dogs same as for people
tramadol 50 mg tramadol 50 mg medicine - stop tramadol addiction
buy tramadol overnight cod legal buy tramadol online us - veterinary tramadol overdose
buy propecia reviews on generic propecia - can i buy propecia over the counter
generic propecia cheap prices for propecia - propecia side effects on women
[url=http://inchinaledlightmanufacturer.com ]led manufacturers [/url]which has often persecuted me, against discouragement, and against the http://inchinaledlightmanufacturer.com led manufacturer in taiwan led manufacturers © 28Sep28; A1053843. Henriette
cialis no prescription overnight generic cialis online uk - cialis cheap
viagra online without prescription viagra no prescription usa - buy viagra safely online
buy cialis cialis heartburn - cialis daily use review
buy cialis cialis jelly sachet - cialis daily low dose
buy tramadol tramadol to buy online in uk - tramadol for purchase no prescription
cheap viagra anatomy spam viagra purchase - viagra online argentina
generic cialis buy cialis online mastercard - can you buy cialis online with no prescription
generic viagra buy viagra online - legal purchase viagra
buy cialis buy generic cialis no prescription - buy cialis philippines
generic cialis cialis daily use 36-hour - generic cialis tadalafil best buys
tadalafil tablets cialis testimonials - cialis jelly review
generic viagra equivalent to viagra for women - buy viagra online using paypal
tadalafil online reputable online pharmacy cialis - how to buy cialis over the counter
generic cialis buy cialis with paypal - safe place order cialis
buy cialis generic cialis daily use - generic cialis overnight delivery
tadalafil online generic cialis 50mg - cialis price check
cialis online no prescription cialis joke video - cialis online best place buy
cheap generic cialis cialis online for sale - can u buy cialis over the counter
cialis pharmacy cialis questions and answers - buy cialis brisbane
tadalafil 20mg cialis online thailand - buying cialis online legal
buy cialis buy cialis online cheap - cialis kopen
buy tramadol online tramadol generic for ultracet - tramadol yahoo answers
buy cialis cialis quit working - safe place order cialis
viagra online viagra online ratings - buy viagra online cheap category
viagra online buy generic viagra dapoxetine online - generic viagra us suppliers
buy soma buy soma online overnight delivery - soma muscle relaxer online
buy cialis cialis upset stomach - cheap cialis prices usa
buy soma online soma medication ingredients - soma 250 generic
soma drug drug soma like - what drug is soma classified as
soma drug soma bras donate - order soma overnight
order soma soma 350 mg addictive - soma quality recordings
soma online soma grand cost - generic soma dan 5513
buy soma soma muscle relaxer over the counter - soma san diego theater
buy generic soma soma for muscle spasms - muscle relaxers like soma
buy soma online soma san diego venue - generic name for soma muscle relaxer
soma no prescription soma - soma intimates models
soma drug soma online prescription - buy somatropin thailand
online soma buy soma online with credit card - soma online offer code
buy retin-a online retin a no prescription usa - buy retin a micro gel pump
buy soma somo 650 - soma pain killer muscle relaxer
buy soma cheapest generic soma - deadmau5 soma san diego tickets
order tramadol online overnight tramadol withdrawal help - purchase tramadol online cod
buy retin a buy retin a walgreens - buy retin-a micro usa
buy tramadol online tramadol addiction effects - tramadol 50 mg cost
tramadol 50 mg tramadol overdose - tramadol for dogs cost
tramadol online pharmacy buy tramadol online saturday delivery - best dosage tramadol
tramadol cheap tramadol 50 mg buy online - tramadol discount coupons
buy retin a retin a micro retin a difference - retin a cream how it works
buy cialis online cheap cialis no prescription - cialis daily needed
buy tramadol online tramadol online rx - buy tramadol online without a prescription
order tramadol online cod tramadol xl - tramadol online no prescription cod
buy tramadol online cod how do i buy tramadol online yahoo - tramadol 50 mg snort
buy tramadol cod fedex tramadol online - tramadol online pharmacy
buy generic tramadol where can i purchase tramadol with a mastercard - buy tramadol no prescription usa
buy tramadol online cheap tramadol withdrawal opiate - get high tramadol 50mg
tramadol generic best place buy ultram - tramadol
buy tramadol online can you buy tramadol in usa - tramadol for dogs with aspirin
buy tramadol online does tramadol hcl 50 mg contain acetaminophen - tramadol expiration
buy tramadol online buy tramadol overnight shipping - tramadol 50 mg high snort
buy tramadol 180 tramadol death by overdose - tramadol 50 mg vs percocet 5mg
tramadol online does tramadol hcl do you - order tramadol overnight delivery
buy cialis online can you buy cialis online with no prescription - buy cialis lilly
buy cialis online how to order cialis online - cheap 2.5 mg cialis
http://buytramadolonlinecool.com/#56411 can you buy tramadol in spain - tramadol withdrawal many days
http://southcarolinaaccidentattorney.com/#31862 carisoprodol expiration - soma 350 mg dosage
This paragraph will help the internet users for building
up new webpage or even a blog from start to end.
Also visit my blog; http://gto120dlaocm402mfos02.com/
Post a Comment
Subscribe to Post Comments [Atom]
<< Home